Fixing Healthcare, Part II

Indianapolis-based Wellpoint is in hot water for raising premiums on individual policy holders by nearly 40%. Except, they’re not really in hot water because no one that can do anything about it got screwed:

WellPoint, in its year-end earnings report, said its medical costs rose 8.9 percent in 2009. And Binns said reform must address the main drivers of rising health-care costs, such as price increases from hospitals and doctors.

Still, some of Anthem’s individual customers in Indiana are left wondering how their rates could jump so much more than that in a single year.

Strickland, 60, the bread distributor, said his premium is about to rise from $301 to $401 a month for a plan that carries a $5,000 deductible.

“It doesn’t bother me that they’re making money,” Herchenroeder, 53, said. “I just don’t see how anyone can justify a 31 percent increase in a year.”

He said that’s how much his WellPoint premiums increased in December — giving him a $941.78 a month premium for a family plan with a $6,000 deductible.

$941.78 a month is more than my mortgage, and almost as much as my mortgage and car combined. That’s $12,000 a year in some cases, or about a third of the average Hoosier’s income. Plus a high deductible! That’s a third of your income that, in most cases, doesn’t even go towards anything!

I’m wondering when our healthcare debate is going to refocus attention on doctors and hospitals instead of insurance companies. It doesn’t bother me that insurance companies make money, either. Most of them don’t make more than a 2% profit each year which isn’t much when you consider any good person or company or government should have 10% of their operating budget in savings.

The insurance companies, or our government, can’t be expected to just lose money on these things. They at least have to break-even, otherwise it’s just an unsustainable mess. Yet, for reasons no one seems to understand the cost of healthcare keeps going up because somehow, hospitals have to keep raising their rates.

For that reason, I’m left to believe that hospitals are seeing expenses go up because of increased demands from something. I doubt it’s doctor and nurse salaries; most of them only make a respectable amount. I doubt it’s equipment – you buy an MRI machine once and you pay it off and it should be good-to-go for a while. I doubt it’s malpractice – that doesn’t seem to add up to much nationally. I doubt it’s drugs because that market is too competitive and generics are always in the pipeline.

Or, it could be that hospitals are so overwhelmed with uninsured people that can’t afford health coverage that hospitals are forced to eat the costs because you can’t let a guy bleed to death and you can’t bleed that turnip, either. That, in turn, leaves the hospital to raise the cost of other services on insured people to help them break even. That translates to higher premiums for those with insurance. It’s a vicious chain right up to the top. The poor person comes in and his expenses keep defying gravity and keep getting dumped up the chain until it reaches the insurance companies, and then you.

If only there were some sort of national healthcare system where people could afford coverage based on their incomes from larger pools of people with competition across state lines…

Want to know when stuff like this is published?
Sign up for my email list.

Photo of Justin Harter


Justin has been around the Internet long enough to remember when people started saying “content is king”.

He has worked for some of Indiana’s largest companies, state government, taught college-level courses, and about 1.1M people see his work every year.

You’ll probably see him around Indianapolis on a bicycle.

Leave a Comment